Data & Privacy

EU Meta Ruling: Why 'Consent or Pay' Models Face New Legal Hurdles Under DMA

2026-11-19 · 14 min read · MeshLaw Newsroom

Source news: "The EU Commission's Meta Decision on "Consent or Pay" Foregoes Competition for Data Privacy Law" (ProMarket) · Search original The following is original commentary written by AI based on facts verified from 2 real news reports (not a translation or copy of the original). See sources at the end.

The European Commission’s April 2025 decision that Meta’s “pay or consent” model violates the Digital Markets Act marks a sharp departure from the European Court of Justice’s 2023 ruling, which had previously validated such models under GDPR when fees were deemed necessary and appropriate. This regulatory divergence creates immediate uncertainty for legal teams advising digital platforms, as the Commission’s stance prioritizes data privacy protections over traditional competition law frameworks. With Meta challenging the decision in European courts and the EDPB strongly recommending a third “ad-free” option to ensure valid consent, practitioners must now navigate a complex landscape where privacy compliance may override established business model viability.

The Shift from Competition to Privacy Prioritization

The Primacy of Privacy Compliance Over Market Competition

The European Commission’s April 2025 decision against Meta represents a fundamental reorientation in how the EU regulates digital gatekeepers, signaling that compliance with privacy-centric provisions of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) now takes precedence over traditional competition law defenses. By ruling that Meta’s simplified "consent or pay" model violated Article 5(2) of the DMA, the Commission effectively decoupled the legality of data monetization strategies from standard antitrust arguments regarding market power and consumer choice. This pivot suggests that even if a business model appears commercially reasonable or competitively neutral, it cannot stand if it fails to meet the stringent privacy safeguards embedded within the DMA’s core obligations.

This shift creates a complex legal landscape where the Commission’s enforcement priorities diverge from established judicial precedents. While the European Court of Justice (ECJ) had previously ruled in July 2023 that "consent or pay" models could be compatible with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) provided the fee was "necessary" and "appropriate," the Commission’s recent stance implies that such economic justifications are insufficient under the DMA. The regulatory body is increasingly treating the DMA not merely as a tool for ensuring fair competition, but as a robust framework for enforcing data privacy standards, thereby overriding the economic balancing tests that traditionally governed competition law disputes.

Key aspects of this regulatory pivot include:

  • DMA Article 5(2) as the Decisive Factor: The Commission focused on the DMA’s specific prohibition against combining personal data across services without valid consent, rather than assessing whether the "consent or pay" model distorted competition.
  • Superseding ECJ Precedent: The decision challenges the July 2023 ECJ ruling by suggesting that meeting GDPR standards for "necessary" and "appropriate" fees does not automatically guarantee compliance with the stricter privacy mandates of the DMA.
  • Regulatory Independence: The Commission’s approach indicates a willingness to enforce privacy standards independently of, and potentially in conflict with, traditional competition law interpretations, prioritizing user data protection as a primary regulatory objective.

Reconciling GDPR Precedent with DMA Enforcement

The Divergence Between GDPR and DMA Standards

The European Commission’s recent determination that Meta’s simple "consent or pay" model violates Article 5(2) of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) marks a significant departure from the legal landscape established by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in 2023. In its July 2023 ruling, the ECJ held that such models could be compatible with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), provided that the fee charged for refusing consent was deemed "necessary" and "appropriate." This precedent suggested that as long as the financial barrier was not prohibitive, users were technically making a valid choice between paying for privacy or accepting targeted advertising. However, the Commission’s new stance argues that this logic fails under the DMA, which imposes stricter obligations on gatekeepers to ensure fair competition and prevent self-preferencing, regardless of whether the consent mechanism appears voluntary under privacy laws.

The core tension lies in how each regulatory framework interprets user autonomy and market fairness. While GDPR focuses on the validity of individual consent, the DMA scrutinizes the structural power dynamics of gatekeepers like Meta. The Commission contends that a binary choice between paying a fee or surrendering data for targeted ads does not meet the DMA’s requirements for fair access and non-discrimination. This creates a complex legal environment where a practice deemed lawful under privacy regulations is simultaneously considered a violation of competition rules. The situation is further complicated by Meta’s introduction of a third option, "additional ads," which offers a free service without behavioral targeting, a move designed to address these concerns but which remains subject to intense regulatory scrutiny.

Key distinctions between the two regulatory approaches include:

  • GDPR Precedent (2023): The ECJ allowed "consent or pay" if the fee was proportionate and necessary, focusing on the validity of user consent.
  • DMA Enforcement (2025): The Commission ruled that simple "consent or pay" models violate Article 5(2), prioritizing fair competition over the mere presence of a paid alternative.
  • Regulatory Conflict: Meta has challenged the Commission’s stance in European courts, arguing that the combined positions of the Commission and the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) are incompatible with existing EU law.
  • EDPB Recommendation: The EDPB strongly recommends a third option (such as "additional ads") to ensure valid consent, a guideline that Meta has adopted but which the Commission’s DMA enforcement may still view as insufficient if the underlying structure remains coercive.

The 'Additional Ads' Option as a Legal Shield

Meta’s response to regulatory pressure involved a structural pivot in its user interface, introducing a third tier often referred to as the "Additional Ads" option. This model moves beyond the binary choice of paying for privacy or accepting behavioral targeting for free. Instead, it offers users a free service that displays ads but explicitly excludes behavioral targeting. By decoupling the absence of payment from the presence of personalized advertising, Meta attempted to create a pathway where users could access the platform without submitting personal data for profiling purposes, thereby addressing concerns about coercive consent mechanisms.

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has strongly recommended this three-option structure for all large online platforms. The rationale is that valid consent under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires a genuine choice. When users are forced to choose between paying a fee and surrendering their data, the voluntariness of that consent is often questioned. The introduction of a non-targeted ad-supported tier provides a neutral alternative, ensuring that users who do not wish to pay are not automatically compelled to accept invasive tracking. This option serves as a critical legal shield, aiming to demonstrate that consent is freely given rather than extracted through economic pressure.

Key aspects of this strategic shift include:

  • Tripartite Choice: Users can choose to pay for an ad-free experience, accept behavioral targeting for free, or accept non-behavioral ads for free.
  • EDPB Endorsement: The regulatory body views the third option as essential for guaranteeing valid consent across major platforms.
  • GDPR Alignment: The model seeks to satisfy the requirement that consent must be specific, informed, and unambiguous, avoiding the "take it or leave it" dynamic.
  • Regulatory Defense: Meta argues that this structure resolves the compliance issues raised by the European Commission regarding the Digital Markets Act (DMA), though the Commission’s April 2025 decision suggests the "consent or pay" model alone remains insufficient.

EDPB Guidelines and the Validity of Consent

The EDPB’s Push for a Third Option

The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has taken a firm stance that the binary choice of "consent or pay" is insufficient to guarantee valid user consent under GDPR standards. Their guidelines strongly recommend that all major online platforms offer a third option to ensure that consent is truly free and not coerced by financial demands. This position directly challenges the traditional paywall model, arguing that when users are forced to choose between paying a fee or surrendering their personal data for targeted advertising, the element of voluntariness required for lawful processing is compromised.

This regulatory pressure contrasts with the European Court of Justice’s (ECJ) earlier ruling in July 2023, which suggested that "consent or pay" models could coexist with GDPR if the fee was deemed "necessary" and "appropriate." However, the EDPB’s guidance raises the bar for what constitutes "appropriate" pricing, effectively signaling that a simple fee-based alternative may not satisfy the requirement for non-coercive consent. By advocating for a third path, the EDPB aims to protect users from what it views as an imbalance of power, where the cost of privacy is prohibitively high compared to the value of their data.

Key aspects of the EDPB’s recommendation include:

  • Voluntariness: Consent must not be undermined by the threat of losing access to a service unless the payment is genuinely optional and proportionate.
  • Third Option Requirement: Platforms should provide an alternative that does not rely on either paying a fee or consenting to personalized advertising, thereby removing the coercive element.
  • Uniform Application: The guidelines apply to all major online platforms, not just Meta, setting a broader standard for the digital economy.
  • Conflict with Business Models: This stance creates friction with business models that rely on monetizing user data or charging for privacy, as it questions the validity of consent obtained under such conditions.

Meta's Legal Challenge and Jurisdictional Conflict

Meta has escalated its dispute with European regulators by filing a lawsuit in the EU courts, arguing that the positions taken by the European Commission and the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) are fundamentally incompatible with existing EU law. The company contends that the regulatory push to dismantle its "consent or pay" model creates a jurisdictional conflict, particularly when viewed against the backdrop of the European Court of Justice’s (ECJ) 2023 ruling. In that decision, the ECJ established that such models could coexist with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), provided that any fee charged for refusing consent is both "necessary" and "appropriate." Meta argues that the current enforcement actions ignore this judicial precedent, effectively imposing stricter standards than those set by the region’s highest court.

The core of Meta’s legal challenge rests on the tension between competition law enforcement under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) and data protection standards under the GDPR. While the Commission ruled in April 2025 that Meta’s simple "consent or pay" model violated Article 5(2) of the DMA, Meta maintains that this interpretation clashes with the EDPB’s own guidelines. The EDPB has strongly recommended a third option—such as Meta’s "additional ads" free service—to ensure valid consent across large online platforms. Meta’s lawsuit suggests that the regulators are overstepping their mandates by demanding structural changes to business models that were previously deemed legally viable under GDPR, thereby creating an unpredictable regulatory environment for digital platforms.

Key points of Meta’s legal argument include:

  • Conflict with ECJ Precedent: The lawsuit asserts that the Commission’s decision contradicts the ECJ’s 2023 ruling, which validated "consent or pay" models under specific conditions.
  • Jurisdictional Overreach: Meta claims the Commission and EDPB are applying standards that are incompatible with the established framework of EU data protection law.
  • Regulatory Inconsistency: The company highlights the disconnect between the EDPB’s recommendation for a third option and the Commission’s strict enforcement of DMA compliance, arguing this creates legal uncertainty.
  • Defense of Business Model: Meta defends its transition to a model including a free "additional ads" option as a compliant response to regulatory concerns, arguing it should not face further penalties under the DMA.

Implications for Big Tech Business Models

The European Commission’s April 2025 determination that Meta’s simple "consent or pay" model violates Article 5(2) of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) signals a significant tightening of regulatory scrutiny on data monetization strategies. While the European Court of Justice previously ruled in July 2023 that such models could coexist with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) if fees were deemed necessary and appropriate, the Commission’s recent stance suggests that compliance with privacy laws alone is no longer sufficient to satisfy competition mandates. This divergence creates a precarious environment for large online platforms, as they must now navigate conflicting expectations where a fee structure acceptable under GDPR may still be deemed anti-competitive under the DMA.

For major tech companies, this ruling threatens the viability of mandatory consent or payment structures by raising the bar for what constitutes a legally defensible alternative. The Commission’s decision implies that simply offering a paid option to bypass data collection may not suffice if the underlying architecture still pressures users into consenting to extensive data processing. Platforms relying on these models face the risk of being forced to redesign their business logic entirely, moving away from binary choices that leverage user data for targeted advertising toward more transparent and less coercive frameworks.

Key implications for big tech business models include:

  • Regulatory Misalignment: Platforms face the challenge of satisfying both GDPR standards for valid consent and DMA requirements for fair competition, which may not always align.
  • Increased Compliance Costs: Companies must invest in legal and technical resources to ensure their fee structures are not only privacy-compliant but also competitively neutral.
  • Model Redesign: The simple "consent or pay" dichotomy is increasingly viewed as insufficient, pushing platforms toward more complex, multi-option interfaces that genuinely empower user choice.
  • Litigation Risks: As seen in Meta’s ongoing legal challenges, platforms may face prolonged disputes over whether their specific implementations of paid alternatives meet the stringent criteria set by EU regulators.

Compliance Checklist for Data-Driven Platforms

Immediate Audit of Consent Architecture

Legal teams must first determine whether their current monetization strategy relies solely on a binary "consent or pay" structure, which the European Commission has reportedly found non-compliant with Article 5(2) of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) in its April 2025 decision against Meta. Unlike the European Court of Justice’s 2023 ruling, which allowed such models under GDPR if fees were deemed "necessary" and "appropriate," the Commission’s recent enforcement action signals a stricter interpretation where the mere presence of a paywall may not satisfy DMA obligations if it effectively coerces users into providing data. To mitigate this risk, platforms should evaluate the feasibility of introducing a third option, similar to Meta’s "additional ads" model, which offers a free service without behavioral targeting. The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has strongly recommended this tripartite approach for all large online platforms to ensure that user consent remains valid and voluntary, thereby aligning with both GDPR standards and emerging DMA expectations.

Strategic Alignment and Litigation Preparedness

Beyond structural changes to consent flows, legal departments must prepare for the jurisdictional friction between competition law and data protection regulations. As Meta has reportedly challenged the European Commission and EDPB positions in court, arguing they are incompatible with EU law, other platforms should monitor these proceedings closely to anticipate shifts in regulatory interpretation. Compliance strategies should not assume that GDPR compliance automatically satisfies DMA requirements; rather, teams need to document the specific rationale for any fee structures or consent mechanisms to demonstrate proportionality.

To operationalize this compliance, legal teams should implement the following steps:

  • Review Consent Granularity: Assess whether current consent requests bundle data processing activities in a way that violates the "freely given" standard, particularly when tied to service access.
  • Evaluate Third-Option Viability: Analyze the technical and economic feasibility of offering a non-personalized, ad-supported tier to reduce reliance on coercive paywalls.
  • Document Fee Justification: If a paid option is retained, prepare evidence showing that the fee is "necessary" and "appropriate" relative to the cost of providing the service without data exploitation, referencing ECJ precedents.
  • Monitor Jurisdictional Conflicts: Track the outcome of Meta’s legal challenge to understand how courts reconcile the Commission’s DMA enforcement with the EDPB’s GDPR guidelines on valid consent.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the EU Commission rule against Meta's 'consent or pay' model?

The European Commission determined in April 2025 that Meta's simple 'consent or pay' model failed to comply with Article 5(2) of the Digital Markets Act. This decision highlights that competition law requirements can impose stricter standards than previous privacy rulings.

How does the ECJ's 2023 ruling differ from the EU Commission's recent decision on Meta?

In July 2023, the European Court of Justice ruled that 'consent or pay' models could be compatible with GDPR if the fee is necessary and proportionate. However, the Commission's 2025 decision under the DMA suggests that such models may still violate competition rules despite GDPR compliance.

What is the 'third option' recommended by the EDPB for online platforms?

The European Data Protection Board strongly recommends that large online platforms offer a third option, such as a free service without behavioral targeting ads, to ensure valid user consent. Meta introduced this 'additional ads' option as part of its revised model to address these regulatory concerns.

Sources

Adopt AI in legal work, carefully

MeshLaw is an AI case-management tool for lawyers. No hallucinations, fully verifiable.

Explore MeshLaw →

← Back to all briefings

AI case management for lawyers — MeshLaw Try it free →